Skip to content

Add Credential Dispute Resolution System (#985)#1

Closed
maztah1 wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
feature/credential-dispute-resolution
Closed

Add Credential Dispute Resolution System (#985)#1
maztah1 wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
feature/credential-dispute-resolution

Conversation

@maztah1

@maztah1 maztah1 commented Jun 30, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

Implements a complete credential dispute resolution system that allows stakeholders to flag and contest fraudulent credentials (e.g., fake university degrees).

Changes Implemented

Core Functionality

  • dispute_credential() - Allows any address to initiate a dispute against a credential with evidence
  • resolve_dispute() - Admin-only function to resolve disputes (upheld or dismissed)
  • get_credential_disputes() - Retrieves all disputes associated with a credential
  • get_credential_status() - Returns the current status of a credential

Data Structures

  • CredentialStatus enum: Valid, Disputed, Rejected
  • DisputeResolution enum: Upheld (credential rejected), Dismissed (credential remains valid)
  • CredentialDispute struct: Tracks dispute details including initiator, reason, evidence hash, timestamps, and resolution
  • Event types: DisputeInitiatedEventData and DisputeResolvedEventData

Storage and State Management

  • Updated Credential struct to include status field (defaults to Valid)
  • Added DataKey entries: CredentialDisputes, CredentialDisputeEntry, CredentialDisputeCount
  • Added ActivityType entries: DisputeInitiated, DisputeResolved

Workflow

  1. Any address can call dispute_credential() with reason and evidence hash
  2. Credential status changes from Valid to Disputed
  3. Admin reviews evidence and calls resolve_dispute()
  4. If upheld: credential status becomes Rejected
  5. If dismissed: credential status returns to Valid
  6. Multiple disputes can be filed against same credential (after resolution)

Testing

Comprehensive test suite includes:

  • Successful dispute initiation
  • Preventing disputes on already-disputed credentials
  • Error handling for non-existent credentials
  • Resolving disputes as upheld (rejection)
  • Resolving disputes as dismissed (remains valid)
  • Access control (admin-only resolution)
  • Multiple disputes on same credential lifecycle
  • Empty disputes list handling
  • Event emission verification

Technical Details

  • Follows existing codebase patterns and conventions
  • Uses existing TTL constants (STANDARD_TTL, EXTENDED_TTL)
  • Integrates with activity recording system
  • Emits events for audit trail
  • Proper authorization checks on all functions

Estimated Time

3 hours (as specified in issue QuorumProof#985)

Related Issue

Closes QuorumProof#985

Checklist

  • Add CredentialStatus enum (Valid, Disputed, Rejected)
  • Implement dispute_credential() - any address can initiate
  • Implement resolve_dispute() - admin-only
  • Implement get_credential_disputes()
  • Add comprehensive tests for dispute flow
  • Update Credential struct with status field
  • Add proper event emission
  • Integrate with activity tracking

- Added CredentialStatus enum (Valid, Disputed, Rejected)
- Added DisputeResolution enum (Upheld, Dismissed)
- Added CredentialDispute struct to track disputes
- Implemented dispute_credential() - allows any address to flag fraudulent credentials
- Implemented resolve_dispute() - admin-only function to resolve disputes
- Implemented get_credential_disputes() - retrieves all disputes for a credential
- Implemented get_credential_status() - returns current credential status
- Added ActivityType entries for DisputeInitiated and DisputeResolved
- Added DataKey entries for dispute storage
- Added DisputeInitiatedEventData and DisputeResolvedEventData events
- Updated Credential struct to include status field
- Added comprehensive test suite covering:
  * Successful dispute initiation
  * Dispute on already-disputed credentials
  * Dispute on non-existent credentials
  * Resolving disputes as upheld (credential rejected)
  * Resolving disputes as dismissed (credential remains valid)
  * Non-admin attempting to resolve disputes
  * Multiple disputes on same credential
  * Event emission on dispute operations
- All new functionality follows existing patterns and conventions
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Add Credential Dispute Resolution

1 participant